At the moment I'm using Shiny's version of Louis's skins, but I'm trying to make my own set based on some of Enayla's more recent skins. Her pixie skins are way better about the shine, although I'm slowly deshining them.
A lot of people like oepu's most recent skins, and corvidophile2 did a default set
here. They're not my personal favorites, but I keep finding Sims they look
right on.
And is it just me, or do a lot of skintones look horribly ashen? There are several creators whose skins I like in theory, but in the game make the Sims look all grayish and dead. I correct a few, but I'm too lazy to do more.